Deckchairs on the Titanic

by Kris_Tuttle on May 1, 2008

We did start the post on SYMC yes­ter­day by stat­ing we had no idea what the quar­terly report would hold.  Investors were happy with posted results and guid­ance.   From our per­spec­tive it only makes the poten­tial down­side more acute if they com­pany does noth­ing to improve their steady per­for­mance decline in cus­tomer envi­ron­ments.  Even though we don’t play for the quar­terly reports we still focus on them to com­pare and con­trast them with our longer-term thesis.

The com­pany started the report by reclas­si­fy­ing a large num­ber of busi­ness seg­ments to present a dif­fer­ent view of the busi­ness to the mar­ket.  (Why would you do this in a fis­cal Q4 ver­sus at the begin­ning of the next fis­cal year?)  In any case we’ve lived in com­pany envi­ron­ments like Syman­tec where “results” often depend more on pre­sen­ta­tion than exe­cu­tion.  This was the case at IBM dur­ing the years they tried to ignore the sub­stan­tial declines in their busi­ness in the twi­light of the 80’s.

The full tran­script is avail­able here to skim. As one can see lots of the state­ments and answers are either obscure or self-serving.  There are plenty of ref­er­ences to “double-digit” growth and “our <fill in the blank> busi­ness is doing great” along with repeated ref­er­ences to the “record” quar­ter.  Man­age­ment even gets away with a revi­sion­ist posi­tion­ing of say­ing they have now posted five straight quar­ters of stronger than expected results despite low­ing guid­ance with the Sep­tem­ber 2007 quarter.

Clearly inter­na­tional was strong for the com­pany.  We were more than a bit sur­prised that nobody had much of a reac­tion to the fact that 6 points of the 13% YoY growth was dri­ven by for­eign exchange.  Unless we mis­un­der­stood the state­ment it appears that the entire growth in deferred rev­enue came from cur­rency effects.  Lead­ing ana­lysts actu­ally said that the growth in deferred rev­enue was strong.  Are they even lis­ten­ing to the infor­ma­tion being presented?

That said we don’t find fault with the report per se.  The com­pany has a strong mix of busi­nesses and recent acqui­si­tions like Vontu are indeed best-of-breed point prod­ucts.   At the same time noth­ing has changed in terms of our the­sis on the com­pany and the stock.  Man­age­ment will be dri­ving the field force to deliver more growth in license rev­enue this year at a time that exist­ing cus­tomers are increas­ingly dis­sat­is­fied with Syman­tec and expect very lit­tle to no spend­ing increases with them.  It could be a very inter­est­ing year for the com­pany and investors.  To the degree that inter­na­tional busi­ness and cur­rency ben­e­fits remain strong, the fun­da­men­tal weak­ness will be masked.

Based on the quar­ter and the guid­ance we would expect the pre­sen­ta­tions on the ana­lyst and investor day on June 12th to be another pow­er­ful mar­ket­ing event which will help stoke enthu­si­asm for what looks like a turnaround.

We main focused on exe­cu­tion which we con­tinue to see as bad enough to jeop­ar­dize busi­ness results in the next few quar­ters. Man­age­ment closed their call stat­ing that F09 is going to be “their year.”

– Kris Tuttle

Tags: ,

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: