Tech EPS estimates may still be too high.

by Kris_Tuttle on September 17, 2008

We’re reminded a lit­tle of the admon­ish­ment “be care­ful what you wish for” in this cur­rent mar­ket.  The finan­cial tur­moil, unwind­ing of high energy and com­mod­ity prices and slow­down in global growth are all here as expected.  Why don’t we feel more happy about it?

Obvi­ously a mar­ket this bad drags every­thing down but it also calls into ques­tion fun­da­men­tals and esti­mates.  It’s been pointed out by oth­ers like Bill Ham­brecht recently in an inter­view that growth rates will slow but bal­ance sheets are in very good shape.  Think of the cash that lead­ing com­pa­nies like Apple and Google are swim­ming in. 

But still we know that things “at the mar­gin” often deter­mine direc­tion and sen­ti­ment for stocks and it’s clear that lower finan­cial sec­tor IT spend­ing and more care­ful con­sumer spend­ing are going to reduce the take up of tech­nol­ogy, par­tic­u­larly things that can just wait a while.  Our friends over at MGI put up a post that points out that while about 20% of tech­nol­ogy spend­ing comes from the finan­cial sec­tor but even more, close to 30% of “lead­ing edge, advanced tech­nol­ogy” comes from there.  To us it means that maybe the expen­sive uptake of new tech­nol­ogy prod­ucts will just be a bit slower than it was going to be. 

Cau­tious con­sumers and slow­ing global growth will cer­tainly push pur­chases to lower price points and elon­gate new prod­uct cycles (Adobe releases CS4 next week and no mat­ter how good it is most will prob­a­bly not be eager to move from CS3 any­time soon.)  No doubt $400 smart phones and $2000 lap­tops may give way to $150 and $1200 ver­sions respec­tively.  In many respects the tim­ing of the small and cheap lap­top PC will be per­fect for this eco­nomic backdrop.

Cur­rent val­u­a­tions seem low but of course the key ques­tion is how much of the slow down is “in the num­bers” right now?  We did a quick and dirty analy­sis look­ing at fore­casts for the top 100 tech­nol­ogy com­pa­nies by rev­enue to see where we are right now.

The Top 100 have rev­enues of just over $1T with a total EBITDA of about $200B.  Based on cur­rent esti­mates rev­enues are expected to grow 8.2% this year and 8.7% next year.  These num­bers are prob­a­bly close to but could come down a point or so.  Earn­ings per share growth expec­ta­tions do look too high though with growth of 24% this year and 18% next.  It feels like the 24% num­ber should be cut in half and the out year would be fine from these lower lev­els.  Athough we don’t have EBITDA esti­mates for all 100 com­pa­nies the ones we do have show growth of 14% this year and 12% next.

Our con­clu­sion is that there are still some neg­a­tive changes at the mar­gin that may keep val­u­a­tions and sen­ti­ment in check for the near term. Since we use a longer term approach in our Intrin­sic Value method­ol­ogy our tar­gets don’t change much, if at all.   We prob­a­bly picked a great time (Octo­ber 1st) to release our model port­fo­lio over at The Cre­ative Destruc­tion Fund.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: