Motorola Back on the Mobile Internet List

by Kris_Tuttle on September 13, 2009

We’ve had a focused Mobile Inter­net theme for the last two years or so and the ini­tial focus has been on Apple, Research in Motion, Google and even Palm as a “spe­cial sit­u­a­tion.“  Need­less to say these stocks and this theme have been on cen­ter stage for some time.

After look­ing at the first new prod­ucts from Motorola based on Android we have offi­cially put them on the list.  Motorola is a major global player despite stum­bling very badly in the years since they intro­duced the hit Razr phone.  (We still have one for pre-paid cards in strange places and it remains an excel­lent phone even by mod­ern standards.)

After bring­ing in a new CEO to focus on the phone busi­ness and build it on top of the Google Android plat­form it appears that Motorola has not bum­bled this time.  The value-added soft­ware makes the mobile device a pow­er­ful net­work­ing and com­mu­ni­ca­tion tool which is what it has become in the last year.

Although being on Android can “cut both ways” in terms of value-add ver­sus com­modi­ti­za­tion, it’s far bet­ter than try­ing to build on a niche OS.  This is where Palm is at a major dis­ad­van­tage with WebOS and Research In Motion may find them­selves in a sim­i­lar state if Android and Apple come to dom­i­nate the mobile Inter­net OS.

The one thing we can say for Motorola is that they have proven that they at least under­stand what is going on in the mod­ern world of the mobile Inter­net and have demon­strated some exe­cu­tion around that vision.  This is far more than we can say for Nokia who so far appears clue­less about what is going on despite the suc­cess of devices like the iPhone and the Blackberry.

From a stock stand­point Motorola is also much more inter­est­ing than the oth­ers at these lev­els.  Apple, Research in Motion and Palm have all had very nice runs and trade at fairly high mul­ti­ples.  At this point few doubt the indus­try posi­tions of Apple and Research in Motion and those stocks trade at lev­els with that expec­ta­tion baked in.  Although Motorola has moved up of late they still have much to prove and the stock has a way to go before one would say that a lead­ing mar­ket posi­tion has been fac­tored into the shares.

We would avoid Palm for now.  The cur­rent price reflects our esti­mate of True Value and with increas­ing com­pe­ti­tion the abil­ity for Palm to pro­duce more upside sur­prises may be dif­fi­cult.  The fact that there are already so many shares of Palm sold short may be the one thing that keeps the shares from going down if things don’t con­tinue to improve for them.

The glimpse Motorola is giv­ing into their mobile Inter­net plan is very pos­i­tive and if they can con­tinue to exe­cute on it the shares remain a bar­gain.  We’re work­ing on a True Value for MOT shares which will help us decide how to posi­tion it in the port­fo­lio over time.

[Dis­clo­sure: At the time of this writ­ing Research 2.0 owns shares of Motorola.]

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: